Victory Is CertainUSS San Jacinto (CG-56) · 1988 to 2023

Appendices


Appendix A — Chronology
DateEvent
21 Apr 1836Battle of San Jacinto
20 Jun 1983Contract awarded to Ingalls Shipbuilding, Pascagoula
5 Oct 1984Construction begins
24 Jul 1985Keel laid
14 Nov 1986Launched (some sources give 11 Nov)
24 Jan 1987Christened; Dr. Wendy L. Gramm, sponsor
5 Nov 1987Delivered to the Navy
18 Jan 1988Fog delays the ship’s arrival at Houston
23 Jan 1988Commissioned at Houston; Vice President George H. W. Bush speaks
30 Apr 1988Port Everglades, Florida, during shakedown, on the weekend of the carrier Kennedy’s visit
13 Oct 198819-gun salute from the ship at Port Everglades closing Navy Appreciation Week
4–20 Nov 1988Fleet exercise FleetEx 1-89
May–Nov 1989Maiden Mediterranean deployment
16 Aug 1990Deploys for Operation Desert Shield
15 Sep 1990Transits the Suez Canal into the Red Sea (some accounts give 14 Sep)
12 Jan 1991Capt. Ecker relieves Capt. Clark (the NavSource roster gives 12 Jan 1990)
17 Jan 1991 (0130 local)First Tomahawk missile fired from the Red Sea; two in the opening salvo and sixteen in all by the NAVSEA evaluation, fifteen by the Navy’s ship history
28 Mar 1991Returns from Desert Storm
Jun 1991Hudson River ship parade, New York
26 Jun – 16 Nov 1992UNITAS XXXIII, a circumnavigation of South America (Argentina, Aug 1992)
4 Aug 1992At Rio de Janeiro; sailors spray water at environmental protesters who reached the berth
1993BALTOPS ’93 and a cruise to northern Europe (photographed at Wilhelmshaven, July 1993)
1994George Washington carrier group: Adriatic, 50th anniversary of D-Day, Villefranche, Operation Vigilant Warrior
16 Aug 1995Unarmed Tomahawk fired from the ship in the Atlantic across North Florida to Eglin Air Force Base
26 Jan 1996Deploys with the George Washington group; 21 Mar, rescue of the crew of the Hofuf
31 Aug 1996Arrives at Port Everglades; open to the public over the Labor Day weekend
26 Feb 1998Deploys with the Stennis group
4 Jun 1998Navy release reports a visit to the ship in the Gulf by the Master Chief Petty Officer of the Navy
28 Nov 2000Deploys with the Truman group
30 Dec 2000Rescues 11 Yemeni mariners
23 May 2001Returns
5 Dec 2002Deploys for Operation Iraqi Freedom
21 Mar 2003Tomahawk launches in Operation Iraqi Freedom
23 May 2003Returns
7–19 Jun 2004BALTOPS 2004
Sep 2005Deploys with the Theodore Roosevelt group
18 Nov 2005Flagship of Combined Task Force 58
11 Mar 2006Returns
5 Nov 2007 – 4 Jun 2008Truman group deployment (Dakar, the Mediterranean, the Black Sea)
27 Apr 2009Chesapeake Bay rescue attempt
Jun 2009First enlisted woman reports aboard
21 Jan – 11 Aug 2010Counter-piracy deployment with Combined Task Force 151
26 May 2010Rescue of the crew of the Al Jawat
13 Oct 2010Enters dry dock at BAE Systems, Norfolk
19 Nov 2010Capt. Nashold relieves Capt. Cordle
25–31 Aug 2011Hurricane Irene sortie
28 Sep 2012Capt. McKinley relieves Capt. Nashold
13 Oct 2012, 1927:15ZCollision with USS Montpelier
1 Nov 2012Enters dry dock at BAE Systems, Mayport, for collision repairs
18 Dec 2012Phillips investigation report
4 Jan 2013Adm. Gortney endorses the report
Feb 2013Truman group’s planned deployment postponed; she had been due to miss it while under repair
22 Jul 2013 – 18 Apr 2014Truman group deployment
2 Apr 2014Capt. Hack relieves Capt. McKinley
Jun 2014Investigation report released under the Freedom of Information Act
10 Jul 2014House Armed Services subcommittee hearing on cruiser and destroyer modernization
15 Jul 2014BAE contract award of $29.8 million for repair work
Feb 2016Capt. Velez relieves Capt. Hack
1 Jun – 30 Dec 2016Eisenhower group deployment
Sep 2017Hurricane Irma relief
9 Oct 2017Defense News publishes a decommissioning schedule placing her retirement in 2022
19 Dec 2017Capt. Farrell relieves Capt. Velez
18–22 Jan 2018Thirtieth-anniversary plankowner reunion at BAE, Norfolk
9 Dec 2019Capt. Crossman relieves Capt. Farrell
17 Jan – 9 Aug 2020Eisenhower group deployment: 161 days at sea by 25 Jun, a record, and 206 days in all (the ship’s own chronology dates the ammunition run to Yorktown 12–14 Jan)
Nov–Dec 2020Cape Verde mission
21 May 2021Capt. Marvin relieves Capt. Crossman
2 Aug 2021Navy Unit Commendation presented for the 2020 deployment
2 Dec 2021 – 8 Sep 2022Truman group deployment
Mar–Apr 2022The Navy’s fiscal 2023 plan proposes retiring the ship as a logistics support asset
12–16 Sep 2022Ammunition offloaded at Naval Weapons Station Yorktown
Jan 2023Thirty-fifth-anniversary reunion
10–16 Apr 2023Fleet Week at Wilmington, North Carolina
12 May 2023Last return from sea in the record, after twenty-six days in the Atlantic operating areas
15 Sep 2023Decommissioning ceremony, Naval Station Norfolk
21 Sep 2023NAVSEA historic evaluation, initial determination: not eligible for the National Register
29 Sep 2023Decommissioned and stricken, by the Naval Vessel Register (the NAVSEA evaluation gives 15 Sep)
16 Oct 2023Begins a tow of about three days from Norfolk to the inactive-ship facility at Philadelphia
4 Nov 2024The Navy extends the service lives of three sister ships, Gettysburg, Chosin and Cape St. George
1 Dec 2024NAVSEA’s annual report lists her among thirteen cruisers found ineligible for the National Register
17–20 Sep 2026Reunion, Norfolk and Virginia Beach

Appendix B — Commanding Officers

The ship had twenty commanding officers in thirty-five years. The Navy’s releases at the 2021 change of command and the 2023 decommissioning count Capt. Christopher Marvin as the twentieth, and a published roster of her captains kept by the NavSource ship-history site lists twenty names that agree with the Navy’s counts at three points: Nashold as the fourteenth, Velez as the seventeenth and Marvin as the twentieth. The table follows the Navy’s releases and the ship’s own account for the changes of command from 2010 on, and the NavSource roster for the captains before that, whose dates the Navy’s releases do not set out. The roster’s dates for the first two captains differ from those in the Navy’s history, and both are given.

No.Commanding officerTenurePrincipal events during command
1Capt. H. Ward Clark Jr.Oct 1986 – 12 Jan 1991 (the Navy’s history); 23 Jan 1988 – 12 Jan 1990 (NavSource)Commissioning in 1988; the maiden Mediterranean deployment, 1989; departure for Desert Shield, 1990
2Capt. Paul W. Ecker12 Jan 1991 (the Navy’s history) or 12 Jan 1990 (NavSource) – 8 Feb 1992 (NavSource)The opening of Desert Storm; return in March 1991
3Capt. Sherman E. Wright Jr.9 Feb 1992 – 21 Aug 1993UNITAS XXXIII and the 1992 cruise around South America; BALTOPS ’93
4Capt. Clifford C. Covington21 Aug 1993 – 25 Aug 1995The 1994 deployment with the George Washington group; the Tomahawk test of August 1995
5Capt. Raymond C. Pilcher Jr.25 Aug 1995 – 24 Feb 1997The 1996 deployment with the George Washington group and the Gulf; the rescue of the Hofuf
6Capt. James A. Woods Jr.24 Feb 1997 – 9 Jul 1998The 1998 deployment with the Stennis group; Operation Southern Watch
7Capt. Paul E. Stanton9 Jul 1998 – 28 Apr 2000The record does not describe this tour in detail
8Capt. Craig E. Langman28 Apr 2000 – 25 Jan 2002The 2000–2001 Truman group deployment; the rescue of eleven Yemeni mariners
9Capt. John C. MacKercher Jr.25 Jan 2002 – 13 Feb 2004The Operation Iraqi Freedom deployment, 2002–2003
10Capt. Alan E. Eschbach13 Feb 2004 – 15 Jul 2005BALTOPS 2004
11Capt. Charles J. Neary15 Jul 2005 – 10 May 2007The Theodore Roosevelt group deployment and Combined Task Force 58, 2005–2006
12Capt. Matthew M. Sharpe10 May 2007 – 27 Mar 2009The 2007–2008 Truman group deployment: Dakar, the Mediterranean and the Black Sea
13Capt. John P. Cordle27 Mar 2009 – 19 Nov 2010The Chesapeake Bay rescue attempt of April 2009; the 2010 counter-piracy deployment; the rescue of the Al Jawat
14Capt. Marshall D. Nashold19 Nov 2010 – 28 Sep 2012Hurricane Irene sortie, 2011
15Capt. William P. McKinley28 Sep 2012 – 2 Apr 2014The collision with USS Montpelier, 13 Oct 2012; repairs; the 2013–2014 deployment
16Capt. Patrick Hack (NavSource gives the surname as Huck)2 Apr 2014 – Feb 2016Return from deployment, 18 Apr 2014; the post-repair period
17Capt. Dennis VelezFeb 2016 – 19 Dec 2017The 2016 Eisenhower group deployment; Hurricane Irma relief
18Capt. Dennis L. Farrell19 Dec 2017 – 9 Dec 2019The thirtieth-anniversary reunion, January 2018
19Capt. Edward M. Crossman9 Dec 2019 – 21 May 2021The 206-day deployment of 2020
20Capt. Christopher E. Marvin21 May 2021 – 15 Sep 2023The 2021–2022 deployment; inactivation; decommissioning
Appendix C — Deployments
No.DatesGroupAreaCommanding officer
1May–Nov 1989Independent Mediterranean deploymentMediterraneanClark
216 Aug 1990 – 28 Mar 1991Desert Shield and Desert StormRed SeaClark, then Ecker
326 Jun – 16 Nov 1992UNITAS XXXIIISouth AmericaWright
4Summer 1993 (dates not established)BALTOPS ’93 and a cruise to northern EuropeBaltic and North SeaWright
51994George Washington groupMediterranean and AdriaticCovington
626 Jan 1996 – end date not establishedGeorge Washington groupMediterranean and Persian GulfPilcher
726 Feb 1998 – end date not establishedStennis groupPersian GulfWoods
828 Nov 2000 – 23 May 2001Truman groupMediterranean and Persian GulfLangman
95 Dec 2002 – 23 May 2003Truman groupOperation Iraqi FreedomMacKercher
10Sep 2005 – 11 Mar 2006Theodore Roosevelt groupPersian GulfNeary
115 Nov 2007 – 4 Jun 2008Truman groupAfrica, the Mediterranean and the Black SeaSharpe
1221 Jan – 11 Aug 2010Combined Task Force 151Gulf of AdenCordle
1322 Jul 2013 – 18 Apr 2014Truman groupMediterranean and Persian GulfMcKinley, then Hack
141 Jun – 30 Dec 2016Eisenhower groupMediterranean and Persian Gulf (Operation Inherent Resolve)Velez
1517 Jan – 9 Aug 2020Eisenhower groupMediterranean and Arabian SeaCrossman
162 Dec 2021 – 8 Sep 2022Truman groupMediterraneanMarvin

At the decommissioning the Navy counted sixteen deployments. Published lists show fifteen; they omit the 1993 cruise to northern Europe, which rests on a photograph of the ship at Wilhelmshaven in July 1993 and on crew recollection (Chapter 15), and whose dates are not established. With it the table comes to sixteen, the Navy’s count, and a list of her deployments compiled by a former crew member in 2025 gives the same sixteen. The ending dates of the 1996 and 1998 deployments are not established.

Appendix D — Awards

The awards credited to the ship differ somewhat from source to source. NavSource lists, among others, the Joint Meritorious Unit Commendation (two awards), the Navy Unit Commendation (four), the Meritorious Unit Commendation (six), the Battle Efficiency “E” (twelve), the Southwest Asia Service Medal (two) and the Humanitarian Service Medal. The Navy Unit Commendation for the 2020 deployment was presented on 2 August 2021.

At the decommissioning ceremony, Vice Adm. Kilby cited fifteen Battle “E” awards, a figure he offered as a rough count. The Navy’s release for the ceremony also lists a Presidential Unit Citation among the ship’s awards. The NAVSEA historic evaluation does not credit the ship with an individual one, and the Navy’s history lists a Presidential Unit Citation for the earlier carrier San Jacinto (CVL-30). These discrepancies are unresolved and would be settled only by the ship’s award letters.

Appendix E — Collision Figures
ItemFigureSource
Time1927:15Z (3:27 p.m. EDT), WSN-7 / NSWC Dahlgren; bell log offset 53 sPhillips report
Press time“about 3:30 p.m.”Navy news
SJA repair estimate≈ $12.2MPhillips report
SJA award$9,691,713 (BAE, initial award, not the cost of the repair)Navy release at the docking, 2 Nov 2012
Navy yearbook, May 2013about $9.7M for the cruiser; at least $32M for the submarineNavy yearbook (Chapter 19, note 55)
MON estimate$30M (NNSY) – $41M (HII-NNS)Phillips report
Preliminary combined> $43MPress
Total to date, 2014$81M ($70M MON)Fleet Forces via Virginian-Pilot
Later BAE award$29.8M, 15 Jul 2014Contract notice
Historic evaluation, 2023about $11M in repairs after the collisionNAVSEA evaluation (Chapter 20, note 1)
Group sail1–25 Oct vs 2–20 OctConflicting accounts
Institutional afterlifeUsed by NAVINSGEN as an operational-risk-management example; Gortney’s endorsement: safety is the “number one priority” of any exerciseNAVINSGEN; Gortney

Appendix F — Glossary

Appendix G — Where the Sources Disagree

These are the places where sources give different answers that the record does not settle, with the version adopted.

Some episodes, among them events of the 1990s and the reunions of 2018, 2023 and 2026, rest on crew recollection or on a single document, and are hedged where they appear.

Appendix H — What the Record Does Not Establish

These are the questions the record does not answer, or answers only in part. Appendix G sets out the places where sources disagree.

Building and commissioning

The record gives the date on which construction began, 5 October 1984, and the dates of the keel laying, launching, delivery and commissioning. It does not say why the first five ships of the class were retired earlier than the rest. The founding date of the Ingalls yard and the date of its purchase by Litton Industries are given from general knowledge and are not tied to a document, and no hull file, acceptance trial report or builder’s trial record has been seen. The anchorage near Galveston in January 1988, the pier assigned to the ship at Houston and the celebration that followed rest on recollection and newspaper coverage, and no log or order confirms them; the day she reached the Turning Basin is not recorded. The Bush Library lists folders for the captain’s reception of 22 January 1988 and the ceremony of the 23rd, but their contents have not been seen, nor have the articles on the ship in the Universal Ship Cancellation Society’s Log for 1988. A call at Roosevelt Roads in early 1988 rests on one recollection, and a visit to Galveston around Mardi Gras in 1989 on two.

The 1980s and 1990s

The record does not give the dates of the gap in the Navy’s carrier presence in the Mediterranean in 1989, the days the ship left Norfolk and came home that year, or the order and dates of her calls at Antalya and Saint-Tropez. The messages reprinted in the 1989 cruise book name Constanta, Romania, as her first assignment, but the date of the call is not recorded, and what the ship did during the contingency operations in the eastern Mediterranean that August is not described. Sources give the Okinawa operation of April 1945 for the earlier carrier of the name as beginning on either 5 or 6 April. One newspaper reported the ship’s sailing for the Gulf in August 1990 on the 15th and another on the 16th. The 1993 cruise to northern Europe has no dates. The reasons for the 1995 Tomahawk test being carried out from this ship, and not from another cruiser, are not recorded. The record of the ship’s maintenance periods in the 1990s is thin and gives no dates for the restricted availabilities or overhauls of the decade. A carrier report of 1998 credits the carrier’s helicopter squadron with the thousandth deck landing qualification on the cruiser without saying whether the count covers the cruise or the ship’s career. The tour of one commanding officer in the late 1990s is not documented in the records seen, and the dates of the tours from 1992 to 2010 rest on the NavSource roster alone. The changes of command held in Houston, a reenlistment at the San Jacinto Monument, a speed of 37 knots during UNITAS and a visit to Halifax in 1999 rest on crew recollection.

The 2000s

The number of Tomahawks the ship fired in Operation Iraqi Freedom, thirty, rests on a single source, the ship’s official biography as reproduced in a data sheet, which misdates the deployment. The record says little about the ship’s service from 2005 to 2007 beyond the Theodore Roosevelt deployment and her time as flagship of Combined Task Force 58.

The collision and its repair

The command investigation, the Navy’s evaluations and the press releases agree on the shape of the collision of 13 October 2012 but not on every figure. The record does not settle the question of which estimate for the repair, about $12.2 million, the initial award of about $9.7 million or a later figure near $11 million, represents what the work cost. It does not say what the purpose of the ship’s dry-dock period in October 2010 was, or whether the availability planned for 2011 took place as planned. A sentence in a Navy article on the crew’s size after the repair is garbled in the copy available. The year in which the ship’s commanding officer received a Secretary of the Navy safety award is not established.

The last deployments

The ship’s chronology and the Navy’s releases differ on the call at Palma de Mallorca in 2014 and on her position off Key West in September 2017. The end date of the 2013–2014 deployment, 18 April 2014, rests on recollection and on the chronology and not on a Navy release. The regional press of January 2013 and the NAVSEA evaluation tie her missing the Truman group’s deployment to her repairs; the ship that took her place is not named in the record. No document seen says which space aboard was to be refitted under the seating contract of August 2021.

Retirement and disposition

The Navy’s 2022 shipbuilding plan lists seventeen cruisers for retirement through fiscal year 2027, while news reports said the last would leave service in that year; the record does not reconcile them. The Naval Vessel Register gives 29 September 2023 for her decommissioning and striking, and the reason the NAVSEA evaluation gives the ceremony date instead is not recorded; the Navy’s administrative message announcing the decommissioning was not consulted. The final NAVSEA evaluation has not been read and its date is not confirmed, and the copy of the initial determination that was read leaves blank the number of comments received during its sixty-day comment period. The record does not settle whether her status at Philadelphia is that of a Logistics Support Asset or of a ship out of commission in reserve, or say what her final disposition will be. No formal proposal to preserve her has been seen, and the outcome of a proposed event in Galveston pairing the battleship Texas with a San Jacinto Day is not recorded. The reunion of September 2026 was held, by the accounts of those who attended, but whether its crew dinner and its tour of the cruiser Gettysburg took place as planned is not confirmed.

Honors and numbers

The record does not settle whether the ship received a Presidential Unit Citation in her own right or how many Battle Efficiency awards she won (Appendix G). The Navy’s count of sixteen deployments is matched by the list in Appendix C only when the 1993 cruise, whose dates are not established, is included. The figures of more than six thousand sailors and more than half a million nautical miles are the presiding admiral’s rough estimates. The 2016 composite training exercise is not dated to the day.

Records sought but not seen

Navy Freedom of Information Act logs show requests by others for the ship’s command operating reports of 1990 and 1991 and for records of unidentified aerial phenomena reported by the Truman strike group in 2022, among whose ships she is named (fiscal year 2023 log), and for her deck logs of 17 January 1991 (2017 log). Whether any of these records were released is not known, and a request establishes nothing about what the records contain. The ship’s command histories, her deck logs, and cruise books other than that of 1989 were not available.

Is something here wrong? Were you there? Do you have photographs?

Corrections, stories and photographs from people who know this ship are welcome. Everything sent is read and checked before anything is posted, and what is posted is kept apart from the history’s own text and marked as coming from a reader.

Do not send classified, controlled or sensitive information. If in doubt, leave it out.

This is:
If this is posted, credit it to:
Have more to tell? The full form asks more questions →